Business tax deductions can quickly become sources of legal conflict when the IRS questions whether an expense qualifies, how it was classified, or whether your business can substantiate its position. Even if your company believes it's fully in compliance with tax rules, there's still the potential for issues like liability, penalties, and disputes.
Recent federal research and development (R&D) changes show just how fast tax issues can get complicated. If you're a business owner, knowing the rules is only part of the issue. You also need to understand how to respond when the IRS disagrees with you. A deduction that seems straightforward on a tax return can become considerably more complicated when the IRS challenges it.
Why Your Business Tax Deductions Can Lead to IRS Disputes
Tax law establishes certain requirements when it comes to which business expenses can be used as deductions. That includes when you can claim them and what kinds of documents you need for support. Disputes can come up when the IRS interprets those requirements differently than your business or doesn't think you've given them enough evidence.
For example, if you record an expense as an ordinary business cost, you need to be clear on its purpose and classify it properly. You also need to keep good records. If you miss any of those areas, you might have more IRS scrutiny than you'd like.
Disagreements don't mean you've done something wrong, because there are many tax provisions with technical requirements and complex definitions. Interpretations can also change, but when the IRS decides to challenge your deduction, something as simple as an accounting issue can turn into a legal dispute fast.
Section 174A and How the Treatment of R&D Expenses Is Changing
Recent changes to R&D deductions show the complex issues your business may be facing. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 included Section 174A, which generally allows businesses to deduct qualifying domestic research or experimental expenses paid or incurred in taxable years beginning after December 31, 2024.
If you have these domestic expenses, you can also elect to capitalize them and amortize them over 60 months or more. Foreign research expenses have different rules, according to the IRS. The September 2026 Internal Revenue Bulletin 2026-39 addresses changes to accounting methods that relate to Sections 174 and 174A.
Changing how an expense is treated can involve more than reporting a different deduction on your tax return. Businesses must also follow the applicable accounting-method procedures, including those addressed in the IRS's 2026 guidance.
If the IRS chooses to challenge your deduction, you may face a tax audit, including questions about where you did your research, what activities led to expenses, and how you allocated your costs.
What Happens When the IRS Challenges a Deduction, and Why Documentation Matters
The IRS may ask you for explanations or supporting documents and may propose adjustments that could increase your company's taxable income or tax liability. If the IRS thinks you underpaid, you might also have interest charges and penalties.
Depending on the circumstances, you may have opportunities to challenge those adjustments, but deadlines and procedural requirements matter. It's important to remember that the IRS’s suggestion of an adjustment isn't the final word on your case. You can provide more evidence and challenge or contest the interpretation or conclusions.
That's why keeping good documentation is so critical. Your business might have a legitimate reason to claim an expense, but if you don't have the evidence to support it, you could end up fighting with the IRS.
Make sure you keep payroll records, contracts, project documentation, and any other materials that talk about the kind of research your company did, where, and how you calculated R&D expenses. That's not just for R&D, either, because other business expenses need similar documentation.
If your tax returns, financial records, and how you explain your business expenses aren't consistent with each other, that can raise questions from the IRS. Good documentation doesn't guarantee success, but it does make your company's position stronger.
When to Involve a Tax Controversy Attorney
Not every IRS inquiry or business tax audit needs an attorney, and some issues can be handled with clarification and more evidence. Still, you may want to work with an attorney if there's a lot of financial exposure or complex tax provisions. Legal counsel can also be important if there are penalties involved or an examination that could escalate into something more serious.
An IRS challenge doesn't automatically mean your business took an improper deduction. But how you respond can affect what happens next. From Rockville, Maryland, and Washington, D.C., to businesses operating abroad, Kundra & Associates helps clients navigate complex tax disputes. If the IRS is questioning your company's deductions, contact us to discuss your options.